Lizzie Borden took an axe.
Gave her mother forty whacks.
But did she?

Three grifters get caught up in the Lizzie Borden murders and it plays itself out one hundred years later.
Seth Harrison has just been discharged from foster care at the tender age of eighteen. He is taken in by Liam, a benevolent sociologist with an agenda. Seth soon discovers that the hallucinations that have kept him in residential care for the past two years aren’t figments of his broken psyche. They are ghosts and they’re haunting him. And the foggy portals he sees? Those aren’t hallucinations either. Follow his journey to Fall River, to the home of Lizzie Borden, to discover the truth about the Borden murders and how Seth’s ancestor played a part in it.
Find out the real story in this magical realism/urban fantasy novel.

The Mistaken Haunting of Seth Harrison

Chapter 1

 Liam could feel the knot tightening in his gut as he pulled into the parking lot of the Bridgewater State Forensic Hospital. No matter how many times he visited the prison, he couldn’t shake the disconcerting feeling that came over him as soon as he passed the first gate. It was the price of being a Sensitive.

He parked his black Mercedes sedan and scanned the parking lot before getting out. He knew someone was watching him. It wasn’t paranoia. It was video security.

Looking at himself in the rear-view mirror, he ran his fingers through long unruly curls, taming them as best he could. He got out of his car and immediately straightened his signature double-breasted black trench coat. It had a small cape over the shoulders like something out of the nineteenth century. He thought the look made him stand out. It did, but not in a good way.

He reached into the back seat for his black leather satchel and closed the car door. Pressing the button on his key fob elicited a thump and a whoop as the car doors locked. He turned and headed toward the prison entrance. Suddenly, he was jerked backward, twisting and slamming into his car.

“What?! What!?” he shouted, swiveling his head from side to side, near panic. He saw no one. Looking further, he noticed his coat, held tightly in the car door.

“God damn it!” He looked around again. This time checking to see if anyone was nearby. He groped around in his pocket for his key fob, inadvertently hitting the alarm button.

The car screamed Whoooop! Whoooooop! Whoooooop!  

“Shit!” Fumbling with the keys, he finally opened the door and silenced the alarm. He slammed the door shut, straightened his jacket and headed to the building, kicking the tire as he went by. He had regained his composure by the time he got to the security checkpoint.

“Hey, Doc,” the guard greeted him as he buzzed him into the lobby. “Having a bit of car trouble?”

“Damn panic buttons,” Liam growled, straightening his coat. “Officer Tindel. Nice to see you.” He made it a habit to learn the names of all the guards he encountered regularly. The personal touch could go a long way if he needed something in the future. He placed his valise on the conveyor belt.

“Still working on that paper?” the guard queried.

Liam dodged questions about his work with academic babble. “Yes. It’s a longitudinal study on behavior modifications based on duration of incarceration, so it’s not likely to be published for another couple of years, pending review from the Forensic Psychology Board at UMass.”

“Sure, whatever you say.” Officer Tindel sent the bag through the x-ray machine where a second guard reviewed its contents. “Go on in.”

Liam advanced through the metal detector, as the guard circled around, meeting him on the other side. “Who can we pull for you today?”

“No one special, thank you. I'm only observing the yard activities today.”

“Suit yourself. Let us know if there's anything you need.”

Liam retrieved his briefcase from the belt. “I certainly will.” He headed down the hallway toward the next locked door.

“I'll call ahead and let them know you're coming.”

“Thank you,” Liam called back.

As a sociology professor at the University of Massachusetts, Dr. Liam McMurty could talk his way into any public or government facility. He simply claimed that he needed information for one paper or another and people were usually eager to help. When he met with occasional resistance, he had two tactics. He either baited them with a mention in his paper, appealing to the ego-driven, or made subtle threats of a poor report to higher-ups in the chain. So far, this strategy had gained him entry anywhere he wanted to visit.

Today he was at Bridgewater State Hospital, a facility for the criminally insane, where security was high, with two concentric razor wire fences circling the property. It was the only forensic psychiatric hospital in Massachusetts and it housed the most notorious criminals, past and present. The Boston Strangler spent some time here in the 1960s before being transferred to the federal prison in Walpole, but most inmates died here, literally fulfilling their life sentence.

He continued down the long gray hallway from the entrance.

“Good morning, Doc.”

“Sergeant.” Liam nodded to the officer as he passed through the locked doors separating the admin offices from the inmate area.

His destination today was the Outer Wall, a six-foot thick barrier of poured concrete that surrounded the entire facility. As he made his way through the stark corridors, the air became increasingly stale with the smell of stone and poor ventilation. He was grateful to get to the next security checkpoint at the bottom of the stairs that would bring him back out into fresh air. There was no x-ray machine here, but the arch of a metal detector did another scan.

“Good morning, sir. Empty your pockets please.” The guard shoved a small dirty plastic bowl at him. “Open your briefcase. Place it on the table.”

“Certainly, officer.” Liam purposefully leaned down to read the officer’s name tag. Sgt. Cameron Borden. “Are you new here, Sergeant Borden?”

“No sir.”

“I don't recall seeing you here before, that's all.”

“Not my usual station. I'm just covering for the day...sir.” The guard barely glanced at Liam, annoyance creeping into his voice.

“Do you know who I am, sergeant?”

“Dr. McMurty, I understand, here to study the inmates for your next paper.”

Liam's chest pumped out slightly at the recognition. “So, you're familiar with my work?”

“I'm aware that you haven't actually published anything in eight years.”

Liam's back went ramrod straight. His defenses went up. “Oh,” he tried not to sneer, “A well-informed prison guard. How unusual.”

“Just doing my job...sir...wondering how a civilian gets permission to walk the P.” The slang was a reference to the Perimeter, a walkway on the top of the Outer Wall that overlooked The Yard, the only outdoor space available to the prisoners. Along the P stood three towers manned 24/7 with snipers.

“Well, Google doesn't know everything, sergeant.”

“No, sir.” The guard reviewed the contents of the bowl and briefcase while Liam passed easily through the security arch.

“All clear, sir.”

“Thank you.” Liam picked up his things and headed up the stairs. He didn't like this new guard. There was something off about him, aside from being an ass. The last thing he needed was an overachiever nosing around in his business. On the other hand, he had to admire the guard for doing more investigation than anyone else had done in the five years he'd been coming here. He decided the man would make a better ally than adversary and didn’t pursue the argument.

Liam pushed through the door at the top of the stairs, took in a deep breath of fresh air and waited a moment for his eyes to adjust to the daylight. The guard in the corner shack a hundred yards away gave him a wave, acknowledging his arrival. Liam waved back a two-fingered salute from an imagined hat brim.

After walking about halfway to the corner, he turned his attention to the interior courtyard. Referred to simply as The Yard, it was about the size of a football field and the most volatile area of the prison. It was empty except for the Yard Guards, a team of six officers specifically trained for this position. An eerie silence floated over the compound as Liam waited for the doors to open and the inmates to arrive. He took the time to study the guards below. Surprising to some, they were not heavily armed, carrying only nightsticks and tasers. The real firepower was with the snipers who could pick off an inmate anywhere in the yard with deadly accuracy.

A loud siren broke the silence as doors clanged open. Inmates flooded the dirt arena. It was a sociologist's playground and any of his colleagues would be quick to point out this behavior or that, but prison social norms were the least of his interests. He was looking for the “Odd People,” rare individuals with mystical or psychic traits that often got themselves into trouble, landing them in either prisons or mental hospitals or, in this case, both.

Today there were close to one hundred prisoners in the yard, some agitated, pushing and shoving other inmates, some over-medicated, shuffling along staring at the ground. The guards in the Yard and on the Wall were on high alert.

Liam had taken out a notebook and was placing hash marks in various boxes as he watched the activity in the yard.

“Seeing anything noteworthy?”

Liam jumped slightly, following it with exaggerated posturing trying to cover it up. It was Sgt. Borden from downstairs. He had made his way to Liam’s side completely unnoticed.

“Ah, well, hard to say, really. Nothing I wasn't expecting. Today's visit was only to confirm my data. Research is all about the details.” The sergeant remained silent. Liam's antenna was up. There was something unusual about this man. Was he an Odd Person? He didn’t seem to be. Then what was it?

“How long have you been here, Sergeant Borden? My studies include the workforce too, you know. What calls a person to this kind of work and so forth.”

“I've been here about two years now. Usually, I'm patrolling the grounds, inside and outside the Wall.”

“Really? I wouldn't think the outside needed much security.”

“It's mostly curious teenagers or homeless guys looking to camp out over by the trees.”

Sgt. Borden was staring out over the wall to the back of the property. In 1855, when Bridgewater first opened as an insane asylum, its compound was over a hundred acres and included a working farm, complete with chickens, cows and sheep. Patients were expected to work as part of their treatment and the farm made the facility almost self-sufficient. Social activists of the 60s condemned it as forced labor and the practice ceased.

The property gradually transitioned into a multi-use facility with the maximum-security forensic hospital occupying the original inpatient domicile and hospital ward. The wall was added in 1969 and topped with razor wire in 1978 following an escape attempt.

“I hear it's haunted out there,” Liam offered. The guards were a superstitious lot and Liam expected a reaction. The sergeant continued his long-distance stare. Was he looking at the Link? Liam couldn't tell.

“So they say,” he nodded, continuing to look into the distance.

Liam took a moment to look him over. Sgt. Borden, about thirty by Liam’s guess, was wearing the standard guard uniform, a black polo shirt and gray chino pants tucked into black steel-toed boots. Liam noticed a chain around his neck. Some guards wore talismans or religious charms for protection.

“I notice you're wearing a chain. Mind if I ask what's on it?”

“What's it to you?”

“Professional curiosity.”

Sgt. Borden reluctantly pulled out the chain. Liam felt a slight energy wave pass through his body. His suspicions were confirmed when the sergeant revealed a Caller Coin, an eight-sided brass medallion, the size of a half-dollar, plain except for two fine lines etched around the edges on both sides with a gothic-styled design in the center. Liam struggled to feign disinterest.

“That's interesting. What is it?”

“Some old relic my grandfather gave me. Said it warded off evil spirits and stuff.”

Liam read the slight increase in tension in Borden’s body. He knew he was lying. “So far, so good?”

“Yeah, so far.”

“Well, thank you, Sgt. Borden. I think I have all I need for today. Do you need to walk me out?”

“Just down to the security check-point. Then you can make your way to the front.” He gestured toward the stairs.

“Maybe I can walk the outer grounds with you someday. Get your view on things.” Liam had been looking for an excuse to go out back ever since he noticed the gray iridescent oval on the outside of the wall four years ago. He strongly suspected it was a Link, tears in the time continuum, that allowed a person to travel to another location instantly, but he needed a closer look.

“I don't see the point.”

“Professional curiosity. A chance to see what remains of the old farm.”

“You're quite the curious guy, Dr. McMurty.”

“Yes, I am, Sgt. Borden. So, what do you say?”

“You'll have to clear it with Admin.”

“But you don't have any objections?”

“I guess not.”

“Excellent.”

 

When they arrived back at the checkpoint, Sgt. Borden stayed behind, studying Liam as he headed back to the entrance. As soon as Liam was out of sight, he pulled a cell phone from his pants pocket, looked around to ensure privacy and pushed a few buttons. 

“You were right,” he said into the phone. “I just bumped into McMurty. He's up to something, I'm sure. He asked to go walking around outback...Yeah, I'll keep you posted.”

 

Once back to his car, Liam allowed himself a grin and a small fist pump of excitement at his amazing find. A Caller Coin! And an excuse to walk around the grounds! He looked back at the old brick building. “Well,” he said into the air. “It looks like my luck keeps getting better and better.”

Links were literally the stuff of legends. Whenever he heard stories of mysterious places, hauntings, or unexplained disappearances, he was quick to check them out. Bridgewater State Hospital was full of these stories and, as it turns out, for good reason. Links were rare and unnoticed by most humans. He was pretty sure Bridgewater State Hospital had one. As excited as he was about his discoveries at the prison, a more interesting prize lay just two buildings over at Home Away From Home Child and Adolescent Treatment Center, his second stop today.

 The Consortium had mocked his visits here as wishful thinking and unlikely to yield anything of value.

“I don't see why you continue to visit those dreary places, Liam. You'd have much more luck following up on the scandal sheets,” Marilisa, the secretary of the Chairwoman admonished him. “They all think you’re wasting your time.”

 As a result, he refrained from sharing his discoveries. Now, he stood by his car staring out over the property, bragging to himself. “One Link, one Caller Coin and Seth Harrison.”

Book Club Discussion Guide for “The Mistaken Haunting of Seth Harrison”

Opening Discussion - First Impressions

  1. What drew you into this story initially? How did the opening scene at Bridgewater State Forensic Hospital set the tone?

  2. Did you suspect from the beginning that Seth wasn't actually mentally ill? What clues pointed toward supernatural explanations?

  3. How effective was the author's world-building in establishing the existence of Links, Sensitives, and Openers?

Character Development

Seth Harrison's Journey

  1. Trace Seth's evolution from believing he was mentally ill to accepting his supernatural abilities. What were the key moments in this transformation?

  2. How does Seth's tragic backstory (losing his parents at age 10) shape his character and relationships throughout the story?

  3. Discuss Seth's relationship with the crystal pendant. How does this family heirloom serve both as plot device and symbol?

  4. What does Seth's reluctance to embrace his powers tell us about his character? Is his resistance realistic?

Liam McMurty

  1. Is Liam a trustworthy mentor figure, or does he have questionable motives? How do his divided loyalties affect the story?

  2. Discuss Liam's relationship with his missing father and how it drives his actions. Does this justify his manipulation of Seth?

  3. How does Liam's role as both protector and exploiter create moral ambiguity in the story?

Brit

  1. What role does Brit serve beyond being Seth's love interest? How does her own supernatural sensitivity contribute to the plot?

  2. How does Brit's background in foster care parallel Seth's experiences in the system?

  3. Does the romance between Seth and Brit feel authentic, or is it overshadowed by the supernatural elements?

The Ghosts - James, Sarah, and Simeon

  1. How do the ghosts function as both antagonists and victims in the story? What makes them sympathetic characters?

  2. Discuss the revelation about their true killer. How does this twist change our understanding of the entire haunting?

  3. What does Simeon's awakening as a "new ghost" add to the story's mythology?

Themes and Symbolism

Mental Health vs. Supernatural Reality

  1. How does the novel critique the mental health system's treatment of individuals with unexplained experiences?

  2. What commentary does the story offer about how society handles those who don't fit conventional norms?

  3. Is there a danger in the book's suggestion that some "mental illness" might actually be supernatural sensitivity?

Family Legacy and Hidden Histories

  1. Explore the theme of inherited abilities and family secrets. How do the revelations about Seth's ancestry affect his identity?

  2. What role does the crystal pendant play as a family touchstone and magical artifact?

  3. How does the 1892 historical storyline enhance our understanding of the present-day events?

Power and Corruption

  1. Analyze the conflict between the Consortium and the King's Legion. What do these organizations represent?

  2. How do the Caller Coins and Guardians function as symbols of power and control?

  3. What does the story suggest about the corrupting influence of supernatural power?

Justice and Revenge

  1. Examine the ghosts' quest for justice. When does the desire for justice become destructive revenge?

  2. How does the revelation of the true killer affect the moral landscape of the story?

  3. What does the resolution suggest about forgiveness and moving on?

World-Building and Supernatural Elements

The Magic System

  1. How well does the author establish the rules governing Links, Sensitives, Openers, and ghosts?

  2. Are the limitations and costs of supernatural abilities clearly defined and consistently applied?

  3. What questions about the magic system remain unanswered, and does this enhance or detract from the story?

The Links

  1. How do the dimensional portals function both as plot devices and metaphors?

  2. What role do the Links play in connecting past and present events?

  3. How does control over the Links represent different philosophies about power and responsibility?

Historical Elements

The Lizzie Borden Connection

  1. How effectively does the author weave real historical events into the supernatural narrative?

  2. What does the connection to the Borden murders add to the story's atmosphere and credibility?

  3. How does the historical timeline enhance our understanding of the supernatural conflicts?

Past and Present Parallels

  1. What parallels exist between the 1892 events and the contemporary story?

  2. How do the historical injustices echo in the present-day conflicts?

  3. What does the story suggest about how past traumas affect future generations?

Plot Structure and Pacing

Mystery Elements

  1. How well does the author balance the supernatural elements with the mystery plot?

  2. Were you able to predict the twist about the true killer, or were you surprised?

  3. How effectively does the author plant clues throughout the narrative?

Action Sequences

  1. Discuss the cemetery battle scene. How well does the author handle action involving both supernatural and human characters?

  2. Are the conflicts between different factions clearly motivated and resolved?

Supporting Characters and Relationships

Sour Puss and the Cemetery Ghosts

  1. How does Sour Puss function as both authority figure and ally in the ghost community?

  2. What role do the cemetery's "dearly departed" play in the larger conflict?

  3. How does the ghost society mirror or contrast with human organizations?

Cameron Borden

  1. Is Cameron an effective antagonist? What motivates his actions beyond simple evil?

  2. How does his family connection to the historical events enhance the story's themes?

Mildred the Cat

  1. What role does Mildred play beyond comic relief? How does her supernatural sensitivity affect the plot?

  2. What does her divided loyalty between Liam and the Consortium suggest about the complexity of the supernatural world?

Ethical and Moral Questions

Agency and Choice

  1. Does Seth truly have free will in his situation, or is he trapped by circumstances beyond his control?

  2. What ethical obligations do those with supernatural abilities have to others?

  3. How do the different organizations justify their actions in pursuit of their goals?

The Greater Good

  1. When, if ever, is manipulation justified for a supposedly greater good?

  2. How do the characters balance personal desires with larger responsibilities?

  3. What does the story suggest about the corrupting nature of power, even when wielded with good intentions?

Writing Craft

Narrative Techniques

  1. How effectively does the author handle multiple timelines and perspectives?

  2. Is the balance between dialogue, action, and exposition well-maintained?

  3. How does the author's use of humor and lighter moments affect the overall tone?

Character Voice

  1. Do the characters have distinct voices, particularly the teenage protagonists?

  2. How authentic do the characters' reactions to supernatural events feel?

  3. Is the dialogue realistic for the characters' ages and backgrounds?

Series Potential and World-Building

Unresolved Elements

  1. What plot threads are left open for potential sequels?

  2. Which aspects of the supernatural world would you like to see explored further?

  3. How well does this book work as both a standalone story and potential series opener?

Character Development Potential

  1. Which characters have the most potential for growth in future installments?

  2. What challenges might Seth face as he grows into his powers?

  3. How might the relationships between characters evolve?

Genre and Literary Context

Urban Fantasy Elements

  1. How does this book fit within the urban fantasy genre? What conventions does it follow or subvert?

  2. How does the author balance the mundane world with supernatural elements?

  3. What makes this story distinctive within the paranormal fiction genre?

Young Adult Themes

  1. What themes in the story particularly resonate with young adult readers?

  2. How does the story address issues of identity, belonging, and coming of age?

  3. Is the romantic subplot age-appropriate and well-developed?

Cultural and Social Commentary

Institutional Systems

  1. What critique does the story offer of institutional care for troubled youth?

  2. How are systems of power (government, medical, supernatural organizations) portrayed?

  3. What does the story suggest about the treatment of marginalized individuals?

Historical Justice

  1. How does the story address historical injustices and their lasting effects?

  2. What role does truth-telling play in achieving justice and peace?

  3. How do the characters work to correct past wrongs?

Personal Reflection Questions

  • Have you ever felt misunderstood or misjudged by institutions meant to help you?

  • What family secrets or histories do you think might exist in your own background?

  • How would you react if you discovered you had supernatural abilities?

  • What would you do if forced to choose between personal safety and helping others?

  • How do you think past injustices should be addressed in the present?

Creative Discussion Activities

  • Research the real Lizzie Borden case and compare it to the author's interpretation

  • Create family trees for Seth showing his connection to Simeon and the historical events

  • Design your own supernatural organization - what would its goals and methods be?

  • Write a short scene from Mildred's perspective

  • Discuss what you think happens next in Seth's journey

Author's Craft Discussion

  • How does Marie LeClaire balance humor with serious supernatural and social themes?

  • What research into mental health systems and historical events is evident in the story?

  • How does the author create sympathy for characters who have been dead for over a century?

  • What writing techniques help readers accept the supernatural elements as believable?

Questions for Further Exploration

  • How might different cultural backgrounds affect how supernatural abilities are perceived and treated?

  • What real-world parallels exist for the discrimination faced by Sensitives and other supernatural individuals?

  • How do the power dynamics in the supernatural world mirror those in our own society?

  • What responsibility do we have to correct historical injustices, even when we weren't directly involved?

These questions are designed to work for different group dynamics, from lighter discussions focusing on plot and characters to deeper explorations of themes and social commentary. They should provide plenty of material for engaging book club conversations!